Germanwings Crash: The Human Element

Posted by Eric Francis

march26-2015.jpg

In this week’s Core Community edition of Planet Waves, Eric looks at the human element in the crash of Germanwings flight 9525. Using Dr. Stragelove as a metaphor, he explores the ways in which that human element thing can be unpredictable, and the ways in which anyone is capable of anything. What is the line between sanity and madness? Does anyone know where it is? Read this week’s Planet Waves.

You may purchase this week’s members’ issue individually here. Curious about getting the Core Community Pass? Read the details and sign up here.

Dear Friend and Reader:

There’s that moment early in Dr. Strangelove, the 1964 masterpiece by Stanley Kubrick, where one of the president’s top advisors is explaining to the president and all of his military leaders how a lower-level officer has managed to start a nuclear war that nobody can end.

Gen. Jack D. Ripper from Stanley Kubrick’s Dr. Strangelove. Ripper is a low-level general who personally declares nuclear war on the USSR. He’s obsessed with communist conspiracies and sexual hangups.

That top advisor, Gen. Buck Turgidson, played by none other than George C. Scott, explains that there exists this policy called Plan R, which is supposedly a ‘safeguard’ that allows someone with little rank to attack the Russians on behalf of the United States.

The alleged safeguard is that the Russians would have known we had a plan to bomb them even if some other incident killed all the top leaders of the U.S. Therefore, using twisted nuclear logic, they would be deterred from bombing us. He reminds the president that he approved it personally.

But then an obviously insane officer who knows all the right codes, a Cold Warrior bureaucrat named Gen. Jack Ripper, pushes the button by invoking Plan R — and then shoots himself. Shooting himself means he takes the ‘recall’ codes with him to eternity — the codes needed to call off the nuclear attack.

The president’s advisers meet. Everyone is trying to figure out what to do. Turgidson then delivers one of my favorite lines in the whole movie. As a fleet of American bombers spreads out across the USSR to deliver their nuclear payloads, he says to the president: “I admit the human element seems to have failed us here.”

What an understatement! And it is indeed the human element that seems to have failed aboard Germanwings Flight 9525. That flight crashed in the French Alps Tuesday morning; the airplane, traveling close to 500 mph, descended from a safe cruising altitude of 38,000 feet and was shredded against the mountains.

The cockpit voice recorder was recovered and upon review by French authorities, they determined that the captain left the cockpit to use the lavatory. He was then unable to re-enter the cockpit, which has a secured door and security code. As I understand it, his security code was blocked from inside the cockpit.

Planet Waves
Recovered voice recorder from Flight 9525. The flight data recorder’s memory card was, we are told, not recoverable.

As the plane descended, the captain can be heard knocking, pounding and then trying to break down the door, which doors were of course fortified after the Sept. 11 attacks.

So based on one probable scenario (and the current officially accepted one), the captain left the cockpit to answer nature calling, then the co-pilot locked him out, and put the plane into a fairly rapid descent, while ignoring calls from air traffic control.

Note, this disturbing recording has not been made public and I have not heard it.

Based on the known (or at least admitted) facts, we can pretty much rule out a medical emergency; had something of a medical nature happened to the co-pilot, he would not have locked the captain out.
Had the plane lost pressurization, everyone would have been affected. There seems to be just one explanation to this puzzle, the one that nobody wants to hear about — the human element.

I’ve cast the charts for the takeoff of Germanwings Flight 9525 and for the crash. These kinds of charts can take a long time to read — charts are usually read in layers and many don’t reveal their secrets easily. Doing my best to apply classical methods, I find these charts as confounding as the Malaysia Airlines disappearance last March.

But a few features stand out. One is that in both charts (the takeoff and the crash), Mercury is applying in a close conjunction to Chiron. There are humanistic and healing-oriented readings of that aspect, which Amanda described beautifully in a diary post on Monday. Then there’s also the less friendly reading, which is delusion and insanity, i.e., something wrong with someone’s mind.

Planet Waves
The chart for the takeoff of Germanwings Flight 9525 has Gemini rising. Mercury is at the top of the chart — in green — conjunct Chiron, which describes mental illness playing a role. Mercury conjunct Chiron has many creative and innovative qualities, but the shadow side can come out as well, especially if factors of circumstance describe the same possibility.

You could say this is the shadow side of Chiron, the one that few people will encounter consciously. Blended with Mercury, there is the message that some people are truly insane, many are a bit insane and we are all capable of some madness and even pathological behavior.

We often fail to account for the overall insanity of our society, with its seemingly endless appetite for death and cruelty. We fail to account for how close to the edge everyone has been pushed, by being soaked in that environment for so long.

Many people do weird things like ‘oppose’ people killing one another, then support the death penalty, warfare and everyone having a gun. We give our kids video games where they are rewarded for committing virtual mass murder, then panic if they get their hands on nude photos.

Germany, the last few times I checked, was still trying to figure out how its society could gear up a system of industrial death camps and murder 12 million people in a few years. Americans don’t really try to figure out their wars; the French are still largely in denial about what they did to the Algerians (or their direct participation in the Holocaust).

So given all this, it’s really not that surprising that someone might, for example, crash an airplane into the side of a mountain because that’s what they want to do.

Planet Waves
Closeup of the takeoff chart, showing the Moon void of course (you can see because it has the highest number of any planet in the chart). The Aries collected in this chart looks impetuous, especially Mars conjunct Eris. You can see Mercury in green on the right, and Chiron, the orange key.

What’s disturbing is that nearly all of us get on one of those airplanes at some point or another, and we know that we’re not just in the hands of the pilots’ skill level, but also in the hands of their sanity or lack thereof. We just assume that the pilots want to get back to their homes and families just like we do. We don’t know these people and we don’t know much about the companies they work for. We just assume.

I am aware that there are going to be many questions and cries of false flag and questioning the official version of events. There is a question about what happened to the flight data recorder. Somehow that data was lost. That will certainly raise suspicions. I cannot rule out a conspiracy, but I can say the charts support a fairly simple version of events that include someone doing this intentionally and motivated by their own impulses.

That might give you pause if you ever consider that often the only thing that divides you from oncoming traffic is a painted line on the highway. So what do you do? You pay attention, you drive your car, and you trust that everyone is going to hold their shit together long enough to get home safely.

Oh, there’s one last metaphor here. What seems to have been a key weapon used to kill 150 people was a ‘safeguard’ installed after the Sept. 11 incident. We are currently being smothered in those ‘safeguards’, though it’s slower and subtler than what we just saw happen this week in the French Alps.

The Human Element in the Libra Total Lunar Eclipse

We are now in the phase between eclipses. There was a total eclipse of the Sun in the last degree of Pisces on Friday, March 20. We are now approaching the corresponding total eclipse of the Moon in Libra on Saturday, April 4.

You might say that this Full Moon eclipse highlights the ‘human element’ of the Uranus-Pluto square. Earlier this month I gave a detailed history of that astrology, along with news events surrounding each of the seven occurrences of the square since 2012.

Planet Waves
Total Lunar Eclipse. Photo by Anthony Ayiomamitis.

Uranus and Pluto are still within one degree of an exact 90-degree (square) aspect. We are in the first weeks of the separating phase, which will last several more years. Next week’s total lunar eclipse happens in a close aspect to the Uranus-Pluto square. The eclipse is across 14+ Aries-Libra, and Uranus and Pluto are in close aspect to that. So we have one of those events that makes a long-term generational aspect personal and immediate.

Just as the total solar eclipse marked the beginning of the separating phase of the Uranus-Pluto era, this total lunar eclipse does much the same thing. But it does so in a personal way, bringing the Moon and and the Sun — the two most personal elements in astrology — into contact with the square. You might say that next week’s lunar eclipse is taking the Uranus-Pluto square personally.

What exactly does that mean? I can sum it up in one compound question. Over the past few years, have you embraced change, resisted change or tried to revert to some past version of your reality?

Then I would add: in these years, have you become more involved with what you say your mission on Earth is? Or have you stepped back, become distracted or given up?

This chart asks another question: what is your relationship to your technology? I see this appearing in the eclipse opposite the Sun-Uranus conjunction. Uranus in Aries describes the self-obsession of technology and how glittery and fun it is. Alternately it could describe the personal revolution that it can represent and that can spread to much wider society. Yet most of the time Uranus, a planet associated with technology, looks like it’s turning the ‘self’ concept of Aries into something robotic.

Planet Waves
Total lunar eclipse in Libra, April 4, 2015.

Are you caught in the glamour or the thrill of your devices, or their considerable entertainment power, or in the narcissistic haze of the selfie? Or have you assigned your technology to the process of actual participation, learning, involvement and self-development?

I have one more question on the formidable question of technology. What do you think immersion in the digital sphere is doing to you? Do you see your friends more or less? Is your attention span improving as you continue to be involved with the digital sphere, or are you finding yourself considering ideas in more superficial ways?

What this whole digital thing is doing to us is the most pressing question of our time. We ask and answer it too casually, if we bother to do so at all — and yet it’s the thing that we’re involved with all the time. I know it doesn’t seem like a very Zen-like issue to ask the meaning of your Droid and how it’s changing your mind and your society, though I see it as an existential question.

In this eclipse, the Moon and the Sun are also square Pluto in Capricorn, for its part a very long-term influence that is describing another. One question this asks is, how lonely do you feel? How lonely do you feel amidst all of this interconnectivity?

One other question from Pluto — do you feel more free, or less free, than you did five years ago?

I offer much more about the implications of this eclipse — including the Pisces angle — in this week’s edition of Planet Waves FM.

Lovingly,

Planet Waves (ISSN 1933-9135) is published each Tuesday morning and Thursday afternoon in Kingston, New York by Planet Waves, Inc. Annual basic subscription rate: $97/year. Core community membership: $197/year. Editor and Publisher: Eric Francis Coppolino. Business Manager: Chelsea Bottinelli. Web Developer: Anatoly Ryzhenko. Astrology Editor: Amanda Painter. Copy Editor: Jessica Keet. Research, Writing and Editing: Planet Waves is produced by a team consisting of Fe Bongolan, Brendan Merritt, Amy Elliott, Judith Gayle, Kelly Janes, Amanda Moreno, Casey Smith, Carol van Strum, Len Wallick, Lizanne Webb and Chad Woodward.

 

 

Planet Waves

Planet Waves

“This is the one? This is the one used by that kid?” A startled shopper wraps his head around the history of the handgun he’s holding. States United to Prevent Gun Violence describes themselves as “a national non-profit organization working to decrease gun death and injury and build healthy communities by supporting and strengthening state gun-violence-prevention organizations.” Image: video still.

Sometimes You Need to Make it Personal

By Amanda Painter

Recently a group calling themselves States United to Prevent Gun Violence (SUPGV) opened a “gun store” in NYC, as a “hidden-camera social experiment to debunk safety myths.” Every gun in the store had a tag detailing the accidental or intentional fatalities in which it had been used.

As the easygoing man behind the counter explains the histories to would-be customers, both male and female, as they shop for their first gun “for protection,” hidden cameras record their reactions. Out on the sidewalk, an interviewer with the group asks what that was like for them, and whether they’re having second thoughts about owning a gun.

Sometimes the political needs to be made personal. As SUPGV says on their YouTube page, “Every gun has a history. Let’s not repeat it.”

 

 

Planet Waves

Total Lunar Eclipse in Libra, Part One

This week I cover the total lunar eclipse in Libra, in the first of two installments. I look at the eclipse and also at the clusters of planets in Pisces, Aries and Taurus, in this easy-to-follow, meditative guide to eclipses, how they work and what they mean…and this eclipse in particular.

 

 

Planet Waves

Your Monthly Horoscopes — and our Publishing Schedule Notes

We have published your monthly horoscopes for April below in this issue. Your extended monthly horoscopes for March were published Thursday, Feb. 19. We published your Moonshine horoscopes for the Virgo Full Moon Tuesday, March 3. Please note, we normally publish the extended monthly horoscope on the first Friday after the Sun has entered a new sign.

 

Planet Waves Monthly Horoscope for April 2015 #1042 | By Eric Francis

 

Aries (March 20-April 19)

Aries (March 20-April 19) — This month will be full of surprises, though mostly you will surprise yourself with your ability to come up with creative solutions to problems that others would dare not touch. The thing you must do, however, is take control of your money. Make sure that your approach to the various challenges of life uses money as the last line of resort. Correspondingly, you would be wise to turn your attention to generating and accumulating money, the better to secure your ability to fulfill your long-term plans. This is going to take determination, a measure of shrewdness and most of all, discipline. Steer as clear as you can of the burdens of others. It’s not that you don’t care; to the contrary, you do. The issue is that others will depend on you if they can, as if calling in old favors or compensation that exist entirely in their imagination. Follow this theme through the next few months — it’s essential that you establish yourself in your actual, present-moment here-and-now rather than being drawn backwards into the past. Point your mind, your senses and all of your intentions forward. Use your intelligence to know where you are headed at any time, and keep turning yourself in your chosen direction of travel — no matter how many times you must choose again.

Hello, Aries? Don’t Miss Your Birthday Reading!

Dear Friend and Aries:

The April 4 lunar eclipse will be impacting sensitive areas of your chart: both your Sun sign (or rising sign) and your relationship house (Libra). You and your relationships are at the epicenter of that event.

Aries (March 20-April 19)

Eric will explain, in plain language, what this means for you — as well as the rest of your solar year’s key messages — in your soon-to-be released Aries birthday reading. You have an opportunity to pre-order your Aries reading now for only $24.95. After it publishes, the price increases.

Some would call recent Aries astrology brutal, others would say energizing; whatever your experience of it has been, Eric knows how to speak to you about it as though he’s been standing with you every step of the way.

In a sense, he has been.

Your Aries birthday reading brings you to the heart of your astrology. It will consist of two audio segments of astrology (approximately 30 minutes each), a tarot reading, images of the charts and tarot spread Eric uses, plus access to last year’s reading for Aries so you can review.

Yours is the sign of action, one known to take a chance and leap ahead with your entire being. Yet it is said that chance favors the prepared mind. Join Eric in your Aries birthday reading, and you’ll be prepared for this year in the ways that truly matter.

Yours & truly,

Amanda Painter

 

Taurus (April 19- May 20)

Taurus (April 19-May 20) — What’s happening in a relationship is an expression of a process within you — one over which you might seem to have little control. That, however, is not true. To establish your dominion over your own mind, the first step to take is to observe yourself carefully. In particular, keep an eye on what most would call ‘unconscious’ processes, feelings, ideas and expectations. Those have power over you to the extent that you withdraw awareness. You will have power over them to the extent that you raise your awareness. Once you start paying attention, you’re likely to notice there are specific ways you’re seeking freedom from a certain kind of confinement that has grown old for you. I would define confinement as a need to remain stable in a certain element of your identity, seemingly for its own sake. But now you are changing in ways you cannot contain in any previous personality construct. You are waking up; you are finding yourself; you have tasted a measure of freedom, and you want more. You may be wondering if you can have all of this without up-ending your life as you know it. That is a question you can only answer through experience, though it’s clear that certain long-standing factors of your existence could use a little friendly shaking up and shaking loose.

Gemini (May 20- June 21)

Gemini (May 20-June 21) — It’s time for you to establish a conscious relationship to the protective forces in your life. You have been through plenty, and most of the situations you were certain were the most dangerous or threatening have turned out to be reasonably easy to handle. This is a demonstration of many factors that are basic to your existence. You might call them luck, but actually your sense of adventure provides you with a certain inoculation against danger. Your conscious willingness to take risks has this odd quality of clearing the way for you. Your charts are describing an invitation to involve yourself in some kind of unusual creative or romantic endeavor. You might feel that this is way over your head, or a bit too dangerous. Really, you seem to be perfectly well sustained and supported by your environment; there are forces standing guard over your life. As part of that, you are being reminded how far is too far, should you ever need to know. Within your chosen range, you have plenty of emotional and artistic territory to explore, and you can do it with gusto. The feeling you want is precisely the one where you sense yourself close to some inner edge; close to a breakthrough; willing to say something you’ve never said in a way you never imagined you would.

Cancer (June 21- July 22)

Cancer (June 21-July 22) — Your professional life is going through an accelerator that you have long suspected was going to kick in at some point, and you may be surprised at how far beyond your own expectations developments in your life take you this month. You will need to influence the flow of your life with some care and subtlety, by applying a conscious strategy. While you’re doing this, the place to invest your energy is into your home. Your home is your grounding; it’s your source of strength and the place where you seek inner harmony. Take advantage of this gift that you have. Keep your living space clean and spend as much time there as you can. Take some tangible measures to improve or beautify your environment. If you find yourself in an unusually ambitious phase, this will help you keep your life in balance. Get enough rest. Nurture yourself to the point where your old insecurities start to seem trivial. This kind of emotional self-care will foster better decisions, but more than that, the appreciation of your success. It’s true that you may feel, at times, like you’re playing a fast game or traveling above the speed limit. It’s vital that you take many conscious moments each day and remind yourself that you have created a life that is well worth living — and live.

Leo (July 22- Aug. 23)

Leo (July 22-Aug. 23) — You may need to carefully balance long- and short-term plans, and make sure that your actions and choices support both as consciously as you can. You are finally starting to figure out that you have more potential, and that there is more to life, than what you’ve had in the past. That’s another way of saying you’ve figured out that you have a future; your own curiosity is making that a kind of irresistible destination. There are other factors in your solar chart that are calling for stability, and a reminder that you remain an example to many people who seek your guidance and your leadership. That calls for focusing on the day-to-day elements of your life; of attending to practical matters with devotion; and of acting in accordance with your values with each decision you make. No matter how far you want to go, or to what exotic or interesting destinations you may feel called, you will get there one step at a time. Your freedom is something you will be able to access in direct proportion to your integrity. One paradox you may be experiencing is how freedom can feel a little strange when all eyes seem to be on you. It’s true that you’re being scrutinized, though not in the ways you may think. In sum, what you accomplish is what matters the most.

Virgo (Aug. 23- Sep. 22)

Virgo (Aug. 23-Sep. 22) — Resist the illusion that others have more going for them than you have going for you. Your charts describe a scenario where you may feel like you’re lacking in some essential ingredients for success. You may have the sensation that you’re looking down a tunnel at some personal qualities you wish you had. But you seem to be holding the binoculars the wrong way. You might even put them down and size up your environment with your bare eyes. If you do, you will see that you have far more in common with the people around you than you imagined, including the fact that they are looking to you for creative inspiration. Then there is the question of money. It seems that the best success can be had by pooling resources or accessing shared resources. From the look of your solar chart, there is no shortage of wealth or abundance around you. You merely face the question of how you’re going to access those resources, which seems to be through one route only — your trusting relationship with others who share a common mission, values and intentions. It would help, in that case, if you drop any prejudices you might have and get busy having real conversations with those you can partner with on your most valued goals. This will work well for everyone.

Libra (Sep. 22 - Oct. 23)

Libra (Sep. 22-Oct. 23) — It is impossible to lose yourself in a relationship, though it’s questionable whether you can find yourself in one either. But you can remember, and you can forget, and your relationships can prompt you to do either. It turns out there are elements of your life that you’re eager to leave behind, which would be another way of saying forget. But that forgetting will have the sensation of clearing something out of the way, as if you’re brushing back a veil, or silencing some persistent background hum that you didn’t realize was clouding your hearing. At that point, you may discover that you’re in an entirely different situation than you thought you were. You may wonder how it is that you missed how solid and stable your life has become, which is something you can prove to yourself if you do so little as tell yourself the story of the past five years in a paragraph or two. The sensation looks like the discovery that you are where you belong, as long as you don’t have any distractions that would skew your perception otherwise. That, and you are in the company of your peers — or rather, one peer in particular. Work with this feeling. Work with the sensation of change as the experience of clarification.

Scorpio (Oct. 23- Nov. 22)

Scorpio (Oct. 23-Nov. 22) — Take care of your health, and make no assumptions or snap decisions. Remember that your body has truly amazing resilience. Know that anything that can possibly ail a person has been cured or resolved, and that a great many issues are the direct result of mental or emotional stress. Your chart is in fact bursting with wellbeing, abundant energy and the quest to do some bold and creative things. Yet you have so much energy that if you go out of balance you might feel like your life is taking its toll on your body rather than supporting your body. Therefore, aspire to balance in the midst of so much rapidly moving energy and so much activity in your environment. Part of balance is aligning yourself with an onslaught of creativity. Imagine that you’re an airplane wing and that if you position yourself correctly, you will experience a sudden lift and gain altitude. Of course, if you’re not quite aligned in that way, you may feel blown around, held down or paralyzed. So make a series of adjustments and even microadjustments until you feel yourself aligning with the energy both within you and around you. Notice your drive to live in a daring way. Give yourself permission to unravel old, nonproductive patterns and establish new ways of being that light up your whole mind.

Sagittarius (Nov. 22 - Dec. 22)

Sagittarius (Nov. 22-Dec. 22) — Take a step back and give people the opportunity to take responsibility for their own existence. You grew tired of your own hard luck stories long ago, and it’s time to be finished with those of others. I’m not, however, saying don’t be helpful when you feel moved to do so. Rather, I’m suggesting that the best help you can offer others is not being distracted by their problems. Rather, focus on your own abundant creativity and allow your existence to shock others to their senses. Celebrate the fact of your energy and the simple fact that nothing will stop you. If you are involved in some kind of professional artistic pursuits, or doing anything that depends on your originality, I suggest you forget your ideas of what people might think. Instead, work in a way that is only in service of your impulse to create. Every artist, lover or adventurer goes through some trepidation about what others might think. You tend to be among the most immune to such thoughts, though you may be having them now, and now is the time to vanquish them. Your real friends are the people who see how brilliant you are, and who treat you like the treasure that you are to them.

If you would like to hear the first section of your Sagittarius, Aquarius or Capricorn birthday reading — or if you’re curious about what a birthday reading is — I have set up this page where you can listen free.

 

Capricorn (Dec. 22- Jan. 20)

Capricorn (Dec. 22-Jan. 20) — Have no illusions about the nature of the responsibility that is demanded of you. What is expected, mainly because you’re wanting it, is nothing other than drive, passion and a creative approach to existence. To do this, it’s essential that you motivate yourself every day and at all times. If you find someone around you saying, ‘let’s get going’, that means wake up and remember to stay three steps ahead of the game. You don’t need stability right now, even though you may crave that because it seems in such short supply. You need, I would propose, the excitement of connecting your entire existence to the purposes you aspire to. More than that, it’s essential that you connect all activity, every last thing that you do, to those same purposes. At your stage of development, nothing can be outside your core mission. Everything must be brought in, connected with, and understood as an element of the same thing, which is you. You still tend to think in the limited terms of security rather than the bold terms of how good your life would be if you dared and succeeded. But nobody else can, in truth, lead you to this place where you know you belong. Others can set examples — and then you can pick up on the rhythm and then take the lead.

If you would like to hear the first section of your Sagittarius, Aquarius or Capricorn birthday reading — or if you’re curious about what a birthday reading is — I have set up this page where you can listen free.

 

Aquarius (Jan. 20- Feb. 19)

Aquarius (Jan. 20-Feb. 19) — Keep grounded, by which I mean stay focused and eat good food. If you were to bounce between concentrated work and keeping your kitchen a productive place, you would feel excellent, and you would nurture the explosion of ideas that seems to be an ongoing phenomenon within you. To say food is another way of saying respecting yourself as a biological entity. The weather is finally getting warmer and you can take advantage of that by getting involved in some physical activity that may have been impossible through the long, dark winter. Your charts are favoring something aggressive, like martial arts or pounding balls in a batting range. Anything you do to this effect will help get you out of your head, which must be an extremely busy place. By relieving that pressure, you will become more productive and better able to focus your ideas into the concentrated form that they want to take. Just remember that while you’re in a body, your mind is in a close relationship to your biology, which brings me back to the topic of food. I suggest you plan a dinner party or other food-based event this month, and re-integrate the idea of nourishment with the idea of a social experience. This relationship needs some cultivation in our current era of history, and you’re just the person to make that happen.

If you would like to hear the first section of your Sagittarius, Aquarius or Capricorn birthday reading — or if you’re curious about what a birthday reading is — I have set up this page where you can listen free.

 

Pisces (Feb. 19- March 20)

Pisces (Feb. 19-March 20) — With Chiron in your sign, it’s easy to feel like despite all you’re doing, you’re not getting anywhere. That’s an illusion distinct to Chiron. Really, the truth is quite the opposite. It’s your long, slow persistence that has got you much further toward some specific goals than you think. One by one, every facet of your life has come up for questioning; every system has been (or will be) subject to maintenance; every agreement will be revised and improved; and in the process, you will get to know yourself as you never have before. If you feel like you’re in an ongoing and endless challenge, I suggest you remind yourself that you’re really living your life. You are situated in a society and in a time of history where there is very little offered easily, to anyone. Even those who exploit others are under the constant assault of paranoia about their particular house of cards falling down. At the same time, you are driven by your ideals and your faith in yourself, and you may wonder if you’ve taken on more than you can handle. You may have — and when you discover that you can, in fact, handle it just fine, you will discover that you’ve stretched your capacities beyond what you imagined possible. Therefore, stand up straight, keep your eyes wide open and do what you are called to do every day.

7 thoughts on “Germanwings Crash: The Human Element

  1. Len WallickLen Wallick

    Eric (and Planet Waves team): Thank you for braving the pain of dealing with this subject matter in order to get to the bottom of so much that distinguishes human existence in our time. Undertaking to contemplate and offer discussion of the perils we have each contributed to creating contributes in turn to help each of us resolve to be part of a solution. For this reason (and many others) Planet Waves continues to constitute an oasis of sanity and positive potential in the world.

  2. goatwool

    Holy Shit ..ya’ll continually blow me away with your work.
    I’m so moved by the articles, in so many ways and by every word and the thoughts behind them, profoundly so by the questions they ask.
    The horoscope included.

  3. Eric Francis Post author

    Here is the transcript from Strangelove:

    Re Germanwings Flight 9525

    Turgidson:

    Well perhaps you’re forgetting the provisions of plan R, sir.

    Muffley:

    Plan R?

    Turgidson:

    Plan R is an emergency war plan in which a lower echelon commander may order nuclear retaliation after a sneak attack if the normal chain of command is disrupted. You approved it, sir. You must remember. Surely you must recall, sir, when Senator Buford made that big hassle about our deterrent lacking credibility. The idea was for plan R to be a sort of retaliatory safeguard.

    Muffley:

    A safeguard.

    Turgidson:

    I admit the human element seems to have failed us here. But the idea was to discourage the Russkies from any hope that they could knock out Washington, and yourself, sir, as part of a general sneak attack, and escape retaliation because of lack of proper command and control.

    Muffley:

    Well I assume then, that the planes will return automatically once they reach their failsafe points.

    Turgidson:

    Well, sir, I’m afraid not. You see the planes were holding at their failsafe points when the go code was issued. Now, once they fly beyond failsafe they do not require a second order to proceed. They will fly until they reach their targets.

  4. aWord

    About “R”

    “Pearson product-moment correlation coefficient, also known as r, R, or Pearson’s r, a measure of the strength and direction of the linear relationship between two variables that is defined as the (sample) covariance of the variables divided by the product of their (sample) standard deviations.”

    Correlation coefficient/Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

    (I have no knowledge as to whether Kubrick had this in mind when writing his satire but find it an interesting, um, correlation.)

  5. Len WallickLen Wallick

    aWord: Your observation is nothing less than brilliant. Of course, there is no way for us to ask Kubrick now whether he had this particular coefficient in mind. Even so, the correlation (if you will) with the situation in the film (and its correspondence to the the analytical methods used by the US Dept of Defense after WW II) is striking. If Pynchon could read this, he would probably look you up and give you a hug, Please accept my virtual hug instead. Thank you!

Leave a Reply