By Judith Gayle | Political Waves
“We know that no religion is immune from forms of individual delusion or ideological extremism. This means we must be especially attentive to every type of fundamentalism, whether religious or of any other kind.”
–Pope Francis to the United States Congress, September 24, 2015
Saturn in Sagittarius certainly hit with an explosion, drawing our attention to all things philosophical and preparing the landscape for fireworks as regards our various religious establishments. Stuff happened, and some so bizarre it’s hard for the Western mind to grasp.
For instance, over 700 souls died, over 800 injured, in a stampede of Islamic hajj pilgrims just outside of Mecca. They were on their way to the traditional ‘stoning of the devil,’ the importance of which might seem reasonable to some of our evangelical brothers and sisters, but leaves most Americans scratching their heads. Indeed, one gent interviewed was too traumatized to continue his pilgrimage and planned to hire someone to do the stoning for him (scratch, scratch, scratch!).
Autumnal Equinox brought pagans across the world together for a celebration. One event in Kentucky (which has had its share of bad press lately) included a Pagan Pride Day which seemed particularly satisfying and well attended. The earth religions continue to exist in small, quiet groups, still cloistered in — as one Wiccan suggested — the ‘broom closet.’
It tickles me that we have an annual Harvest Festival, here in the Pea Patch, piggybacking on the earth-religion traditions while entertaining consumers of Amish jams and produce, local barbecue and handmade goods with serenades of old timey Christian revival hymns. If they only knew!
Born a Baptist, I sang along while working the Democrat’s booth last weekend, handing out buttons urging progressive activism while appreciating the nip in the air, the falling leaves, and the deep fellowship of community gathering. Here in the country we’ve forgotten a lot, but not the fecundity and generosity of Mother Earth. Should we humans begin to deflesh our beliefs and traditions, we would invariably find the good strong bones of the natural world at their base.
Of course, the whole concept of religiosity lit up like a Christmas tree here in America as the Pope hit Washington D.C. like a dose of salts. Conservative politicians flinched, Progressives hoped, and lapsed Catholics reconsidered, as the force that is Francis arrived with his signature warmth and expected candor. Give the man his due, he’s fearless. He insisted on traveling in a little Fiat — no bubbled popemobile for him — lunching with the homeless rather than the Congress, and even working the crowd line, allowing the occasional selfie.
On a political note, you may be surprised to learn that tanning enthusiast and Merlot drinker John Boehner has only been leader of the House of Representatives since 2011. Funny, it feels so much longer to me — and for him as well, it appears. Bringing the Pope to town has long been reported as the top entry on his bucket list, so it’s no surprise to learn that John, a devout Catholic, burst into tears during their initial meeting. What was surprising, however, even shocking, was the announcement that John has had enough of wrangling contentious Baggers. He will leave Congress in October, throwing water on the growing fire in the belly of his more ideological comrades to depose him.
Baggers are hell-bent on shutting down government over the funding of Planned Parenthood, something neither John nor Mitch McConnell in the Senate have stomach for, given the ramifications of the last government shut down. This has resulted in an assault on John’s speakership. According to The Hill, sharks have been circling for several weeks, a number of Reps eager to step into leadership should a coup occur.
So here’s the bad news: you can bet all of them are more aggressively right-wing than John. In fact, Establishment politicians everywhere, take note: the fat’s in the fire now!
The timing is synchronous on this, since the Pope’s visit seems the goad that pushed the Speaker into a decision he’s delayed since Eric Cantor lost his seat as Majority Leader in 2010, primaried by a Bagger who has offered little but fringe politics since. The replacement Majority Speaker, Kevin McCarthy, would be the default to step into John’s place, but that’s not a sure thing. McCarthy has a reputation of being easily bought and sold to the highest bidder — something the Baggers call “succumbing to the Borg” — and it’s their votes that are needed to enthrone him. There are others lining up, of course. Paul Ryan, failed VP candidate and remaining ‘young gun’ from a decade past, comes to mind, and there are others just as philosophically constricted and ambitious waiting in the wings.
As covered so well in Fe’s piece, I suspect John decided to go out in the blinding light that is Francis, hitting a high note of sorts. He’s got a point. The El Papa persona is beloved even by those who have no use for his Church, thanks to this man who has brought his Jesuit sensibilities to the Chair of St. Peter. He is perceived as compassionate, temperate and flexible, although his attractiveness belies his seriousness. Appropriate, I think, to a man whose Sun sits on the mysterious and compelling Galactic Center.
While we can truly appreciate how much gravitas Francis brings to his plea to our better angels — as illustrated by these quotes — and how that has shone light on what our world and nation so badly need, there is surely little change in the repressive doctrinal imperatives of the Catholic Church herself, nor should we expect any. In fact, the remainder of the quote at the top of the page holds up a mirror not just for us, but for Francis and his church as well:
A delicate balance is required to combat violence perpetrated in the name of a religion, an ideology or an economic system, while also safeguarding religious freedom, intellectual freedom and individual freedoms. But there is another temptation which we must especially guard against: the simplistic reductionism which sees only good or evil; or, if you will, the righteous and sinners. The contemporary world, with its open wounds which affect so many of our brothers and sisters, demands that we confront every form of polarization which would divide it into these two camps. We know that in the attempt to be freed of the enemy without, we can be tempted to feed the enemy within. To imitate the hatred and violence of tyrants and murderers is the best way to take their place. That is something which you, as a people, reject.
Kudos all the way home for the Pope’s plea to world leaders to restore equality, opportunity and justice in a waiting world, but how can we attempt to come to equality when women are denied reproductive rights? How do we entertain equality of opportunity when women are forced to carry and care for ill-conceived children with few resources at their disposal? How do we contemplate justice when women have not been ratified into the Constitution, and are still treated as property on subliminal, even conscious, levels?
As a native Californian, I can tell you that the canonization of Padre Junipero Serra — who militarized the mission system to conquer the indigenous population under the guise of religious conversion, killing enough to constitute cultural genocide — has rubbed not just Native Americans the wrong way, but many of us who have carefully studied history. This controversial action may be a matter of Francis not seeing the larger picture of colonization, but that seems unlikely, given his previous commentary on American imperialism. More likely suspect is the infallibility of the Catholic priesthood in its hierarchical and paternalistic tradition that bestows upon ‘the chosen’ godlike qualities, no matter their personal sins.
What do we say to the survivors of sexual victimization who discover that this Pope praised his bishops this week for their handling of sexual scandals, characterizing their behavior as both courageous and generous? Vatican watchers argue that this was commentary on the (eventual) rapprochement of victims in response to the Pope’s launch of a Vatican tribunal to punish clergy who try to cover abuse, and his commission to discover how best to help survivors. Yet the Church continues to fight legal battles to protect priests from the consequences of their actions. Again, it’s important to note that in Church doctrine, priests are more than mere humans, subject only to the judgment of the Almighty, and add that there is a large contingent of clerics in the Vatican hesitant to see that judgment become secular.
Republicans, who have co-opted religion in the last thirty years and rewritten the Gospels to suit themselves, have gotten over their initial spit-take over the Pope’s comments and are making it clear that he should get his nose out of their business. In their view, secular matters and religious matters are evidently as unmixable as sacred oil and holy water. Hypocritical, much, you ask? Best not to forget that money is the god we worship on these shores and power is the exchange required for access.
The very fundamentalism Francis warns against infects us all, it appears. Still, he has VERY successfully succeeded in changing the conversation, taking the focus off so much that seems out of our hands while pointing us back to our responsibility to create with ethics and kindness, reestablishing the Golden Rule as the commonality that must prevail within the human spirit if we are to succeed as a species. Those with ears to hear, as our biblical traditions tell us, will hear, and others will drag their feet. That’s the way of the world, and, as we’ve heard it said so often: Rome wasn’t built in a day.
Yet many hands have come together to build it, now, more than we know. Last week we also celebrated the 34th annual United Nations International Day of Peace, with a focus this year on “different parts of society working together to strive for peace.” Here’s a link to Deepak Chopra illustrating that principal within a very small group, and another report from Forest Whitaker, actor, activist and UNESCO Special Envoy for Peace and Reconciliation, discussing the one-on-one interactions that are required if we are to make the changes our hearts desire. Consider them the petrie dish upon which our evolution rests, growing and spreading as a gentle alternative to all the dispiriting things that howl and strut and beg our constant attention.
The Pope coming to the U.N. at such a time seems another of those synchronous moments, sternly urging cooperation toward international justice and compassion, end of conflict, and environmental stewardship. As is the custom of this Pope, he paints a big picture but he puts a human face on it; this week, the face of the crowd awaiting his touch are the children and the homeless. That is exactly the face we need to see, my dears. And this is where we all — you and I and those we interact with every day — must begin to lean in.